Columbia Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Columbia Basin Fish and Wildlife Program
SOW Report
Contract 60571: 2002-032-00 EXP SNAKE R. FALL CHINOOK LIFE HISTORY - USGS
Project Number:
Title:
Snake River Fall Chinook Salmon Life History Investigations
Stage:
Implementation
Area:
Province Subbasin %
Basinwide - 100.00%
Contract Number:
60571
Contract Title:
2002-032-00 EXP SNAKE R. FALL CHINOOK LIFE HISTORY - USGS
Contract Continuation:
Previous: Next:
56574: 2002-032-00 EXP SNAKE R. FALL CHINOOK LIFE HISTORY - USGS
  • 64576: 2002-032-00 EXP USGS SNAKE R. FALL CHINOOK LIFE HISTORY
Contract Status:
Closed
Contract Description:
This project will be conducted by the US Geological Survey (USGS), US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS),  the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), NOAA Fisheries, and the University of Idaho.  This goal of this project is to understand the mechanisms underlying Snake River juvenile fall Chinook salmon life history diversity and its consequences to management activities such as transportation and flow augmentation. It also seeks to quantify mortality risks that ultimately affect population productivity.

This project will explore two main avenues of research. First, we will explore the potential mortality risks faced by subyearlings that delay seaward migration and adopt a reservoir-type life history. These include predation and exposure to chronic low levels of total dissolved gas (TDG) found in the Clearwater River during summer flow augmentation. We will also continue our sampling of food resources for both subyearling and reservoir-type fall Chinook salmon and the role they play in life history diversity.  Second, we will develop otolith microchemistry as a tool to determine juvenile life history and origin from the otoliths of returning adults.

Many of the subyearling fall Chinook salmon produced (both hatchery and natural) in the Clearwater River delay their seaward migration and ultimately adopt a reservoir-type life history. Much of this delay occurs in the last 4 miles of the Clearwater River and in the area just downstream of its confluence with the Snake River. This is important because mortality of delaying fish due to predation is likely one of the costs of fish adopting a reservoir-type life history. We propose to examine predation as a potential cost (in terms of survival) to fish that delay seaward migration. With the implementation of hatchery supplementation and increase in natural production, the abundance of subyearlings is far greater today than it was 15 years ago when the last subyearling predation studies were done. Therefore, predation may pose a significant risk to subyearlings and may reduce the productivity of the Snake River population. We will estimate the loss of subyearlings to predation, which will indicate whether predation is a significant problem. Managers could then use that information to decide whether predator control is warranted through changing sport harvest regulations for smallmouth bass and channel catfish. In addition, subyearling vulnerability to predation may be increased by exposure to low levels (up to 109%) of TDG that are present in the Clearwater River when summer flow augmentation is implemented. This is important because the thermal benefits summer flow augmentation provides to migrants in the lower Snake River might be offset in part if low levels of TDG compromise subyearling behavior and performance and thereby increase predation risk. Our proposed experiments on TDG exposure and predation susceptibility will determine the magnitude of this risk.

The life-history complexity of Snake River fall Chinook salmon has hindered efforts to manage this ESU. For example, the existence of an overwintering behavior in a portion of the population has complicated our ability to estimate survival through the hydropower system. In addition, because many of the yearling migrants move downstream after PIT-tag detection systems are disabled in the fall/winter, we have limited information on migratory patterns of these fish, which comprise a substantial proportion of returning adults. Because of this uncertainty, major modeling efforts, such as COMPASS modeling and life-cycle modeling of the Interior Columbia Technical Recovery Team, were not able to model the population dynamics of Snake River fall Chinook, and there is a strong desire with the region to rectify this problem. In addition, it is still unclear whether Snake River fall Chinook benefit from transportation. Until we have a better understanding of this life-history complexity, particularly the habitat usage of overwintering juveniles, it will be difficult to efficiently manage the entire ESU. Effective management of reservoir-type fish will require an understanding of the details of their life-history, including the proportion of juveniles that exhibit the strategy, where they over-winter, when they initiate downstream migration in the spring, and estuarine residence time.

Our proposed otolith work is important because it will useful for identifying fish origin and juvenile life history patterns from returning adults. Currently, many of the adults that pass Lower Granite Dam, where a portion is collected for broodstock, are unmarked. These unmarked adults comprise fish of hatchery and natural origin, fish produced in different spawning areas and hatcheries, and fish with both ocean-type and reservoir-type juvenile life histories. Because this information is currently lacking, it complicates run reconstruction and introduces uncertainty in resulting estimates of different population segments. Run reconstruction is critically important to determining whether progress toward recovery is being made and if goals are likely to be met. Our work will contribute to life cycle modeling for fall Chinook salmon by removing some of the uncertainty in run reconstruction. This approach will be more reliable for determining whether fish are of hatchery or natural origin than scale pattern analysis, the accuracy of which has recently been questioned. Furthermore, it will allow us to determine the hatchery or river of origin for each fish, how long fish spent in different rearing environments, and where they overwintered. This approach has a large advantage of being less expensive and labor-intensive, and with fewer restrictions than methods like telemetry, which have been used in the past. In addition, it is also more useful for collecting data and making inferences at the population level. Telemetry as a tool to study juvenile life history is often limited by small sample sizes (not being able to capture enough fish), tags that are too large for smaller fish, tags that do not last long enough, tag effects on behavior and survival, and not adequately representing the population of interest. Our approach will enhance ongoing run reconstruction by providing information on the proportion of different juvenile life history types that contribute to the adult population and will support inferences made at this level. It will provide insight into which rivers and rearing areas (including the estuary) are most productive, which should be useful for focusing research, management, and recovery actions.

We will use established peer-reviewed methods to collect and analyze predation data so our results can be compared with those of past studies. We will collect smallmouth bass and channel catfish by electrofishing and hoop nets, respectively, throughout the subyearling outmigration. Predators will be tagged and released to subsequently estimate their abundance using a mark-recapture analysis. Stomach contents will be examined to describe predator diets and to estimate the number of subyearlings consumed. Predator abundance and consumption estimates of subyearlings will be used to estimate the annual loss of subyearlings. We will continue with monthly food resources sampling to determine if prey items such as Neomysis and Siberian prawns are also important to predators of juvenile fall Chinook salmon.  Laboratory trials will be used to assess predation vulnerability of subyearlings exposed to various TDG and temperature regimes that could be encountered in the lower Clearwater River and the confluence area. Microchemistry to determine juvenile life history will be performed on otoliths collected from adults at Lower Granite Dam and taken to Lyons Ferry and the Nez Perce Tribal hatcheries. Otoliths from known-origin fish and water samples from different rearing environments will be collected to validate methods and chemical signatures of water sources. This study will take place in the Snake and Clearwater rivers and the lower Snake River reservoirs. Predation work will be conducted in the Snake and Clearwater River arms and the confluence area in the upper portion of Lower Granite Reservoir. The Clearwater River and the confluence area will be the focus of TDG work. Life history information obtained from otoliths will span the entire Snake and Columbia rivers to the estuary. Our proposed study will take place from FY12-14. The USGS and USFWS will conduct all predation food resources work and will participate in the otolith work. The PNNL will be responsible for conducting the TDG-predation experiments. The NOAA Fisheries and the UI will be responsible for conducting the otolith work.
Account Type(s):
Expense
Contract Start Date:
04/01/2013
Contract End Date:
03/31/2014
Current Contract Value:
$807,915
Expenditures:
$807,915

* Expenditures data includes accruals and are based on data through 29-Feb-2020.

BPA CO:
BPA COTR:
Env. Compliance Lead:
Contract Contractor:
Work Order Task(s):
Contract Type:
Contract (IGC)
Pricing Method:
Cost Reimbursement (CNF)
Click the map to see this Contract’s location details.

Full Name Organization Write Permission Contact Role Email Work Phone
Paul Chittaro National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration No Interested Party paul.chittaro@noaa.gov (206) 861-7617
William Connor US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Yes Interested Party william_connor@fws.gov (208) 476-2242
Deborah Docherty Bonneville Power Administration Yes COTR dldocherty@bpa.gov (503) 230-4458
Israel Duran Bonneville Power Administration No Env. Compliance Lead induran@bpa.gov (503) 230-3967
Elizabeth Gordon US Geological Survey (USGS) No Administrative Contact egordon@usgs.gov (509) 538-2299x241
Paul Krueger Bonneville Power Administration Yes F&W Approver pqkrueger@bpa.gov (503) 230-5723
Alec Maule US Geological Survey (USGS) No Supervisor amaule@usgs.gov (509) 538-2299x239
Khanida Mote Bonneville Power Administration No Contracting Officer kpmote@bpa.gov (503) 230-4599
Kenneth Tiffan US Geological Survey (USGS) Yes Contract Manager ken_tiffan@usgs.gov (509) 538-2972
Seok Wilson US Geological Survey (USGS) No Administrative Contact shwilson@usgs.gov (509) 538-2299


Viewing of Work Statement Elements

Deliverable Title WSE Sort Letter, Number, Title Start End Complete
Ensure environmental compliance requirements are complete A: 165. Complete environmental compliance requirements 03/31/2014 03/25/2014
Collect smallmouth bass for tagging B: 157. Collect smallmouth bass for tagging 09/30/2013 09/13/2013
Tag smallmouth bass with Floy tags C: 158. Tag smallmouth bass with Floy tags 09/30/2013 09/13/2013
Estimate smallmouth bass abundance D: 162. Estimate smallmouth bass abundance 12/31/2013 12/31/2013
Collect predators for diet information E: 157. Collect predators for diet information 09/30/2013 09/13/2013
Sample predator diets F: 157. Sample predator diets 09/30/2013 09/13/2013
Analyze predator diets G: 162. Analyze predator diets 02/28/2014 02/28/2014
Estimate fall Chinook loss to predation H: 162. Estimate fall Chinook loss to predation 03/30/2014
Collect food availability data I: 157. Collect food availability data 03/31/2014 01/15/2014
Analyzed food availability data J: 162. Analyze food availability data 03/31/2014
RM&E Technical Annual Report and BiOp annual report for Jan 2013 - Dec 2013 K: 132. RM&E Technical Annual Report and BiOp annual report for Jan 2013 - Dec 2013 03/01/2014
Fulfill all administrative tasks with quality products and in a timely manner. L: 119. Contract and project management for 2002-032-00 03/31/2014 03/25/2014

Viewing of Implementation Metrics
Viewing of Environmental Metrics

Primary Focal Species Work Statement Elements
Chinook (O. tshawytscha) - Snake River Fall ESU (Threatened)
  • 4 instances of WE 157 Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data
  • 1 instance of WE 158 Mark/Tag Animals
  • 4 instances of WE 162 Analyze/Interpret Data

Sort WE ID WE Title NEPA NOAA USFWS NHPA Has Provisions Inadvertent Discovery Completed
A 165 Complete environmental compliance requirements 04/01/2013
B 157 Collect smallmouth bass for tagging 04/01/2013
C 158 Tag smallmouth bass with Floy tags 04/01/2013
D 162 Estimate smallmouth bass abundance 04/01/2013
E 157 Collect predators for diet information 04/01/2013
F 157 Sample predator diets 04/01/2013
G 162 Analyze predator diets 04/01/2013
H 162 Estimate fall Chinook loss to predation 04/01/2013
I 157 Collect food availability data 04/01/2013
J 162 Analyze food availability data 04/01/2013
K 132 RM&E Technical Annual Report and BiOp annual report for Jan 2013 - Dec 2013 04/01/2013
L 119 Contract and project management for 2002-032-00 04/01/2013
M 185 Periodic Status Reports for BPA 04/01/2013